Film & Television Series

The Shadow of Your Smile: Criterion’s “Vampyr” Box

criterion, criterion blog-a-thon, vampyr, carl theodor dreyer
The 2008 “Vampyr” Criterion Box Set. Loaded with historical goodies.

SkeletonPete Says…
Though I normally end a post with the “SkeletonPete Says” section I think it appropriate to preface this particular blog entry with some introduction to its genesis.

This piece is only one small part of the Criterion Blog-A-Thon that officially began yesterday. The Criterion Collection is noted for its restoration of aging film elements, and attention to detail in its bonus features, often producing what most consider definitive DVD and BluRay releases.

Thanks and kudos to Aaron (Criterion Blues) Ruth (Silver Screenings) and Kristina (Speakeasy) who created and are administering this massive, 200 plus post, Blog-a-geddon. It is unlikely I would have endeavored to revisit Vampyr or Carl Theodor Dreyer’s ethos had it not been for the impetus of this online event. Film buffs who trawl the Criterion Blog-A-Thon should have enough to read until December 2020. Please send the blog posts you like some social media (#CriterionBlogathon) and comment love, and follow the ones that you think will float your boat in the long run.

criterion, criterion blog-a-thon, vampyr, carl theodr dreyer
Absolutely over the moon to be awarded this recognition from the folks at the Criterion Blogathon.

I will be handling this subject on two levels and in two installments. This first rumination on the film and overview of the Criterion DVD package will be followed later in the month by an artistic response to Vampyr, an outgrowth of this writing project that I did not expect to arise but would like to share.

Why Vampyr…
On a personal level, Vampyr has been a long term tantalizing mystery that was only solved satisfactorily with the release of Criterion’s DVD package in 2013. I was first exposed to the film as a set of still images found in the pages of Carlos Clarens’ book The Illustrated History of the Horror Film. I purchased that book in 1967 upon its release in paperback form. It was heady stuff. Though I had been a “monster book” fan for some time by then – diligently collecting copies of Famous Monsters of Filmland, Castle of Frankenstein and others off the newsstand – this was something different. I’m not sure I can claim to have fully understood the scholarly nature of Clarens’ work at the time, but it certainly was different from the “Horrorwood, Karloffornia” style puns of FMoF mag, and it set me on a path to ferret out (and obsess over) more arcane information about my favorite genre.

Around the same time, penny saving yielded me the wherewithal to purchase 8mm copies of F. W. Murnau’s Nosferatu (1922,) The Lost World, and Lon Chaney Sr.’s Phantom of the Opera (both 1925,) which I ran endlessly through my family’s home movie projector, but Vampyr was elusive. When I finally got to view it for the first time it was on a pre-cable TV UHF broadcast. UHF was that other – enigmatic – bandwidth that came in via the circular antenna supplied with your TV. At best I could pull in a dodgy, shaky and snowy image, but this was the frequency where John Zacherle’s Disco-O-Teen Party lived so I’d put up with anything.

I watched intently through the static but unfortunately that first encounter was unfulfilling for a teenage “monster kid” living on a diet of Chiller Theater screenings. Where were the monsters? I was perplexed and archived it away in the brain cells, nearly forgotten until I was reintroduced to Dreyer in a college film 101 course via The Passion of Joan of Arc (1928).

criterion, criterion blog-a-thon, vampyr, carl theodr dreyer, illustrated history of the horror film, carlos clarions
My original copy of Clarens’ “Illustrated History of the Horror Film” holds a place of honor in my book collection.

Passion, Turn to the Left…
The Passion of Joan of Arc is renown for its reflection of the human psyche through the director’s use of intense close-ups. The inner mind of the characters is reflected through their facial gestures filling the screen to the displacement of all else. Vampyr on the other hand appears to bring us directly to the source, inside the id of our protagonist, to experience dreamlike, sometimes multiple, views of reality. The film plays less as a narrative than as a series of separate images. Though a sound film, it plays like a silent. Working almost exclusively with non professionals, Dreyer reduces the acting requirements to a limited palette of movement that distills the viewing experience to what seems  a series of still moments.

Vampyr does not progress so much as it… drifts. It follows its own tidal flow. In fact the meager bits of actual exposition afforded the audience become obtrusive amidst the surreal core of the film. DVD Commentator Tony Rayns makes a point of noting that Vampyr has more in common with Jean Cocteau’s Blood of a Poet and Luis Buñuel and Salvador Dalí’s Un Chien Andalou than it does with Universal’s Dracula. I’d call Vampyr a visual tone poem.

criterion, criterion blog-a-thon, vampyr, carl theodr dreyer
Vampire crone from Grey’s coffin bound view. One of “Vampry’s” classic still moments.

I’m On the Outside Looking In…
Lead character David/Allen Grey (Baron Nicolas de Gunzburg) is presented as a cipher of the supernatural. His experiences are often viewed through windows or doorways suggesting that he is seeing events taking place on another plane. This reaches its zenith as Grey witnesses his own interment and trip to the cemetery through the coffin transom. The vampire peering into the coffin from Grey’s point of view has become one of the film’s most memorable and printed images.

Although director Dreyer set out to create a financially successful film utilizing popular gothic tropes, art ultimately trumped box office. The film rebukes the “heavy” old dark house chiaroscuro of its genre mates for a stylized look that Dreyer described as a “muddle of grey and white.” That look has become Vampyr‘s historical hallmark but the groundbreaking style clearly bewildered its target audiences. The tempo of Vampyr makes Tod Browning’s Dracula seem like part of the Fast and Furious franchise. At least one group of early viewers nearly rioted, demanding their money back.

The film was ultimately a commercial failure and likely contributed to Dreyer’s following nervous breakdown. This is not surprising based on the director’s model of filmmaking. It’s what André Bazin and Francois Truffaut later coined as autuer theory in the French film magazine Cahiers Du Cinéma. While recognizing collaboration as a necessity of filmmaking, Dreyer saw the director’s vision as the prime goal of the production team, which had to be fully understood before individual efforts could begin. A failure leaves no one else to blame. He didn’t make another film until 1943.

criterion, criterion blog-a-thon, vampyr, carl theodr dreyer
2008 Criterion Collection “Vampyr” First Edition Box Set with Essay Booklet and Script.

Criterion Collection Inspection…
Now to the actual artifact that drives this Blog-A-Thon. For clarification I’m writing specifically about The Criterion Collection’s Vampyr box set. That is the first edition released in 2008, which is out of print and has been superseded by the March 2015 release. My understanding is that the 2015 package DOES NOT include the printed materials I mention here, though all DVD supplements appear to be the same.

Included in the first edition slip case are a nicely designed foldout for the two DVD’s that also houses an illustrated 42 page essay booklet, and Writing Vampyr a chunky digest that contains the original script and Joseph Sheridan Le Fanu‘s “Carmilla.” The inclusion of Le Fanu’s novella is a nice touch, it’s an important seminal work every fan of vampire lore must read, but Vampyr has only a tenuous connection to its plot. Check Project Gutenberg for Le Fanu’s In A Glass Darkly that includes another influence on the film, the short story “A Room At the Dragon Volant.”

Disc One presents the film in two renditions sourced from a high definition digital transfer of Martin Koerber and Cineteca di Bologna’s 1998 restoration of the original German version. Koerber’s printed essay relates some of the tribulations of the process. He points out that Vampyr was filmed silently, with separate takes of the actors mouthing their lines in German, French and English. Audio was added later at UFA Studios in Germany. Many extant copies of the film are cobbled together from different language takes. A second version with English text and “new and improved” subtitle translation is also included. Tony Rayns, who you will usually find giving context to asian cinema discs, handles the audio commentary with solid insights on both the film and the director.

Disc Two gives us three valuable extras. To me, it’s where this package truly shines, and it is worth noting that there is very little overlap of materials across all of these supplements. Joreen Roos‘s 1966 documentary Carl Th. Dreyer features a lengthy, career spanning, interview with the director and includes snippets of praise from Truffaut, historian Henri Langlois, and Henri-Georges Clouzot (Les Diaboliques) filmed at the premiere of Gertrude in 1964. Dreyer discusses how his use of mise en scene forms a statement about the personalities of the people who inhabit those spaces. In Vampyr the cluttered interiors of the family mansion can be seen to represent the earthly attachments of the living, while the white washed walls of the vampire’s lair are a blank slate to reveal the projections of cavorting phantoms. These shadows often have a life of their own, disconnected from their corporeal hosts, a still startling effect Francis Coppola repeated in his Bram Stoker’s Dracula (1992).

criterion, criterion blog-a-thon, vampyr, carl theodr dreyer
Corot’s Orpheus and Eurydice was just one visual influence on Dreyer’s “Vampyr” mise en scene.

The German censors’ deleted scenes become part of Caspar Tybjerg‘s Visual Essay also on Disc Two. Those scenes could not be reintegrated into the film because of Dreyer’s subsequent edits. The overview also points out the artistic influences on Vampyr and Dreyer’s other films. Henry Fuselli’s Nightmare, Corot’s Orpheus Leading Eurydice from the Underworld, Jean de La Fontaine’s Death and the Woodcutter are all compared to their cinematic heir.

Dreyer’s 1958 radio broadcast cannot be beaten… think of it as a TEDtalk from the beyond

For pure doctrine, the 1958 WBAI radio broadcast of Gideon Bachmann‘s The Film Art series cannot be bested. There is no outsider interpretation. It is solely the director explaining his prescribed methodology for expanding cinema beyond its technical adherence to nature. Hearing these theories of art and style directly from the man – what they are and what they are not – and on how filmmaking should evolve is priceless. Think of it as a TEDtalk from the beyond.

Dreyer’s main goal was always simplification, breaking a scene, a set, or a performance down to its essence. In his own words he strove for a “cleansing of the motif of all the elements that do not support the idea.” It is not so much minimalism as it is aiming towards an abstraction that ultimately leads to symbolism. He professes that a filmmaker’s goal must be “master” to the inherent realism of the photographic medium to create a poetic and stylized (not mannered) “psychological reality.” An artistic transformation based on the disregard for physical reality.

SkeletonPete Says, Again…
Preparing this blog has been an enjoyable exercise in the style of research and critique that made me want to write in the first place. The aforementioned Illustrated History of the Horror Film did not just fuel my desire to view the films assayed, (many of which, by the way, have been released by Criterion) but also to journalize the experience. By the early 1970’s I was producing a stapled together mimeo fanzine (the blog of its time) called Tempest, and doing my best to report and expand on my favorite genre films. It was a great learning experience.

I hope I’ve made you curious enough to screen Vampyr for yourselves and formulate your own opinions. Comments are welcome.

Below is a sneak peek at the Dreyer inspired art I’m currently working on.

criterion, criterion blog-a-thon, vampyr, carl theodr dreyer
Going for the gauzy in a series of paper cut projections I’ll be posting more of.

Discover more from

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading